Can alopecia and hereditary thinning (AGA) occur at the same time, and how can they be distinguished?

Can Alopecia Areata and Androgenetic Alopecia (AGA) Occur Together?
How to Tell Them Apart

Hair loss is common and can stem from different causes. Two frequent types are alopecia areata (an autoimmune condition) and androgenetic alopecia (hereditary thinning, AGA). Although these are distinct disorders, they can—and sometimes do—occur at the same time. Understanding their differences helps guide diagnosis and treatment.

What Are Alopecia Areata and AGA?

• Alopecia Areata

  • An autoimmune attack on hair follicles.
  • Sudden, patchy hair loss anywhere on the scalp (or body).
  • Affects men and women of any age.
  • Often reversible, but can progress to more extensive loss (alopecia totalis or universalis).

• Androgenetic Alopecia (AGA)

  • Genetic sensitivity of hair follicles to dihydrotestosterone (DHT).
  • Gradual thinning following a recognizable pattern:
    • Men: receding hairline, crown balding.
    • Women: diffuse thinning over the top of the scalp.
  • Typically begins after puberty and progresses slowly.

Can They Happen at the Same Time?

Yes. A person with underlying AGA may also develop alopecia areata, or vice versa. Co-occurrence can complicate the hair-loss pattern, with both patchy and pattern thinning present. Recognizing overlapping signs is key to choosing the right treatments.

Why They Occur: Underlying Mechanisms

• Alopecia Areata

  • Immune cells (T-lymphocytes) target anagen (growth-phase) hair follicles.
  • Follicles enter a resting phase (telogen) prematurely, leading to shedding.
  • Exact trigger unknown; genetics and environment play roles (Gilhar et al., 2012).

• Androgenetic Alopecia

  • Hair follicles produce more 5α-reductase type II, converting testosterone to DHT (Sawaya & Price, 1997).
  • DHT shortens the anagen phase and miniaturizes follicles over time.
  • Inherited trait with varying onset and progression.

Key Clinical Differences: Alopecia vs AGA Difference

Feature	Alopecia Areata	AGA
Pattern	Discrete, round/oval patches	Frontal recession, crown thinning
Onset	Sudden	Gradual over years
Hair pull test	Positive at patch margins	Usually negative
Exclamation-mark hairs	Short, broken hairs narrowing proximally	Absent
Scalp inflammation	Peribulbar “swarm of bees” lymphocytes	Minimal to none
Family history	May or may not be present	Often a clear pattern in relatives

Additional Clues on Examination and Trichoscopy

• Alopecia Areata

  • “Exclamation-mark” hairs (wider tip, narrower base).
  • Black dots (destroyed hairs at the surface).
  • Yellow dots (follicular keratin plugs).

• AGA

  • Variation in hair shaft diameter (miniaturization).
  • No inflammatory dots or short broken hairs.
  • Dermoscopy shows perifollicular discoloration in early cases.

Diagnosing Co-existing Alopecia Areata and AGA

1. Patient History

   • Rate of hair loss (sudden vs slow).
   • Family history of pattern baldness.
   • Any recent illnesses, stress, or autoimmune diseases.

2. Clinical Exam

   • Map out patches vs diffuse thinning.
   • Perform a hair pull test on patch edges and diffuse areas.

3. Trichoscopy (Dermatoscopy of the Scalp)

   • Identifies miniaturization, exclamation-mark hairs, black/yellow dots.

4. Scalp Biopsy (if unclear)

   • Alopecia areata: peribulbar lymphocytic infiltrate (“swarm of bees”).
   • AGA: follicular miniaturization without significant inflammation.

Why Distinction Matters

• Treatment Choices Vary

  • Alopecia Areata: corticosteroid injections or topical immunotherapy.
  • AGA: DHT blockers (finasteride, dutasteride), topical minoxidil.

• Prognosis Differs

  • Alopecia Areata can remit spontaneously or relapse.
  • AGA is progressive without lifelong treatment.

Managing Both Conditions Simultaneously

• Coordinate Therapies

  • Continue DHT-blocking treatments for AGA even if immune therapy is started.
  • Monitor for side effects (e.g., scalp irritation, systemic steroids impact).

• Support Scalp Health

  • Gentle hair care, avoid traction hairstyles.
  • Nutritional support (protein, iron, vitamins).

• Regular Follow-Up

  • Track hair density and patch recurrence.
  • Adjust treatments based on response and side effects.

When to Seek Professional Advice

If you notice sudden patches of hair loss or accelerating thinning, it’s important to get a clear diagnosis. For an initial assessment of possible autoimmune hair loss, you might consider doing a free, online symptom check for Alopecia Areata.

Always speak to a doctor about any serious or life-threatening symptoms. Sudden, widespread hair loss may sometimes signal underlying health issues that need prompt attention.

---

Summary

• Alopecia Areata and AGA are distinct but can co-exist.
• Key differences lie in pattern, onset, and microscopic signs.
• Accurate diagnosis relies on history, exam, trichoscopy, and occasionally biopsy.
• Treatment goals and choices differ—address both conditions if they overlap.
• Speak with your healthcare provider for personalized advice and to rule out other causes.

If you’re concerned about hair loss—whether patchy or patterned—consult a dermatologist or qualified doctor for evaluation and tailored treatment options.